gall and gumption

Sunday, April 08, 2007

Is It Lies Or Is It Fiction?

I have been searching for over a week for the issue of The New Republic with the piece about David Sedaris in it. Why can I not find one? Via Romenesko I find this Jack Shafer piece at Slate. It seems, according to TNR writer Alex Heard, that Sedaris has been making up stuff for his true stories. (I’m reserving judgment on the piece until I can get hold of a copy of TNR.) The part about Sedaris is on page 2, if you want to skip the story of the soldier who made up some war experiences.

But then you’d miss the socko opening.

If you've never embellished an anecdote to get a bigger laugh from your drinking companions, please stand up. If you've never lifted an emotional story from your kid brother's life or from a book you've read and then plugged it into your own narrative, you can stand up, too.
If you're still sitting, stand up and join the other liars. Everybody embellishes and steals a little, and some of us do it a lot.
Why do we lie? When talking about our own histories, we lie because we fear—quite rightly—that unadorned our autobiographies are too dull to interest anybody. Plus, the true lies we tell around life's campfires are mostly harmless. So what if I sharpened a punch line or boosted the pathos a little at a dinner party? Social listeners don't demand the Associated Press' high standards of accuracy from storytellers. If anything, they expect a little fiction marbled into the facts.


"If you're still sitting, stand up and join the other liars." Oh yeah? Well fuck you too! What? Oh sorry I didn't get the joke, hahaha he's a liar too so if this isn't true it's because he's a liar and what am I doing calling him a liar when I’m just another liar -- if I say I’m not a liar I’m lying hahaha! So we all find ourselves wallowing together in the mud hole, what fun. Now what do they call that little bit of editorial jiu-jitsu? Journalism? Humor?

That “quite rightly” is a nice touch. You poor, pathetic, pedestrian dullards.

I’ll tell you what really annoys me about this song and dance about the AP reporter’s high standards of truth. All storytelling is fictive. The driest AP business story – a summary of United Widget’s unremarkable annual report -- is fictive. The form of a straight news story is prescribed for a number of perfectly sound practical purposes: economy of space, speed (pressure of deadline or pressure of events), avoidance of ambiguity in matters of fact, avoidance of appearance of bias about facts, because it’s part of the record. And there’s nothing inherently wrong with that, as you can see whenever you read a piece of well-executed objective reporting. The journalist selects and edits, leaves out facts, makes all sorts of judgments that are not visible on the page. Some of these formal judgments are made for the journalist beforehand, and some judgments are made later in the process, for other reasons (Thanky, Tom.). Just because you can’t see them doesn’t mean they haven’t been made. Yes, I’m deliberately making the best possible case for straight news reporting here. For the worst case, watch CNN for about half an hour. Shafer’s AP reporter – any news reporter -- is really only accountable to one standard: the accuracy of his factual assertions. But where is the accountability for all those other judgments? There isn’t any. Not that there’s all that much of any other kind of accountability either, come to think of it, as Glenn Greenwald points out yet again.

“The lies we tell around life’s campfires are quite harmless.” This statement is, if you will pardon the expression, not true.

You’ve all I’m sure encountered the sort of long maudlin human-interest newspaper and magazine story, the one where the writer has worked his way up to the privilege of using techniques like irony and “dramatization.” From a literary perspective, they’re unbelievably bad. Because they too work with a narrow range of permitted literary devices. And these literary devices are all clichés. I remember at J-school the reverence with which people would cite that one Gay Talese story about Joe DiMaggio, the one where Talese never actually talks to DiMaggio, as if this were an unparalleled act of literary daring, permitted only to the most seasoned and proven professional with years under his belt. From imbecilities like this, you see, you get to Sedaris. The Talese story uses fictional techniques to jazz up facts but only in the approved way, that is, with a sort of hard-boiled sentimentality that falsifies not facts but feeling.

There’s a beautiful symmetry to all of this when it is now alleged that Sedaris has been using claims of fact to jazz up his fiction.

Another public storyteller whose personal recollections don't jibe with reality is David Sedaris. Alex Heard's examination of Sedaris' nonfiction in the March 19 New Republic reveals the humorist taking broad and routine liberties with the facts in pursuit of laughs.

Sedaris' stories derive their punch from the fact that they're supposed to be true, a standard he embraces in the introduction to his 1997 collection Naked. "The events described in these stories are real," Sedaris writes. Even so, nobody expects a humorist to apply the absolute faithfulness to characters, dialogue, and events in his stories that an AP reporter brings to a congressional-hearing dispatch. No scold, Heard bends like a contortionist to accommodate Sedaris, writing that it's OK for a "humorist to recreate dialogue that captures the general spirit of how a conversation unfolded But this artistic license doesn't give humorists the right to remember their stories more vividly than they actually happened and still call them real. If humorists pipe lines of dialogue like a playwright (as we now know Sedaris does) or remold scenes from life like a novelist (as we also know he does), they're basically writing fiction and should cop to it. If we label Sedaris' pieces fiction, are they as hilarious? I think not, and I think Sedaris knows that, and I think that's why he presents them as nonfiction.


Does Shafer think that it’s Sedaris or fiction in general that suffers from the lack of “punch?” I can’t tell. But I do remember that the disgraced James Frey had the same story when he was found out: that his fabrications would make more of an impression on his readers if he said they were true. So I start to wonder if this bizarre notion has taken hold in some way in some of the murkier corners of the publishing industry. “It’s a great story but it’ll have more punch if it’s true!” The word “true” now discounted to meaning something slightly less than “authentic.”

Without having read the TNR piece, but with memories of a couple of Sedaris’ books, I’m not surprised to hear of these questions. I find that Sedaris’ books just fit so neatly into a certain school of “memoir” writing, there seemed to be a whole outbreak of them in the mid- to late 1990s. I read these stories and can imagine a lot of clever people sitting around slightly tipsy and laughing (Shafer’s drinking buddies, I suppose), and I’m also thinking that the stories are well-worn, stereotypical, told too often, slick. They lack any sense of exploration or discovery, any sense that these writers might happen across an experience whose meaning they can’t snap up with their know-it-all cleverness.

If you stroll through Borders Books on a Sunday afternoon and come out of there feeling vaguely depressed, it might be because of the sight of all those “Mommy has quit her publishing job, married and moved to the suburbs to take care of little Chesterfield and Davenport while Daddy works in the city ” books. (Sedaris at least spares us that!) The campy covers of the fiction ones look exactly like the campy covers of the nonfiction ones.

Sedaris is as good at this sort of thing as it’s possible to get. He’s a genial writer, certainly. But the kinds of faults I’m describing are internal, unrelated to with any external condition of fact: they are problems of attitude. If something fails as fiction you can’t save it by suddenly attaching the label “True!” to it. Truth can save bad writing in journalism (and only a narrow spectrum of journalism, at that). But it can’t save fiction; here’s the amazing thing. It can’t even save most badly written things that are true. (I remember once when I was teaching writing at UCSB this big guy showed up silent and sort of glowering through each meeting of the class. About midway through the quarter he turned in a story about a guy who had broken his leg. I read it to the class, anonymously, and people began to find fault with the writing, which was shrill, pretentious, and violent. Predictably when these faults were pointed out the writer blew up at me and told me I couldn’t possibly understand his writing because I had never had a broken leg. Well, you know, I shouldn’t need to have a broken leg to be able to judge a piece of writing. Did he bring the story in the hopes that maybe I had had a broken leg somewhere in my past? What about all those people who haven’t been murdered who are reading murder mysteries?)

Compare any of these books with, say, Diana Athill’s Instead of a Letter, published more than 50 years ago. Athill could easily have been one of these people. She, too, was a bright, witty, attractive young woman who went into publishing, except her fiancé dumped her and – because she really loved him – it very nearly broke her spirit. For years afterwards, she just never felt all right, she was carrying a deep sadness. Whenever I think of this story I wonder if she was aware, when she was writing this book, of her own courage in having lived through it so uncomplainingly. She just kept going, limping along with this injury, not always, apparently, completely conscious of how much it had hurt her. It’s almost as though she wrote the book to inquire into this defining experience and the long shadow it cast over her youth. The difference between Athill and the AP reporter is that Athill has all the editorial leeway that the AP reporter doesn’t have. But Athill isn’t using this leeway to jazz up the facts and impress her friends; she’s using it to discover the truth.

The lies we tell around the campfires of life aren’t any less lies because they haven’t been collected into a book. That’s ridiculous. The harm they do is this: they make it harder for us to know what the truth looks and feels like. Which is hard enough as it is.

24 Comments:

At 9:27 AM, Blogger Chuckling said...

Funny, I've been pondering these same issues. My observation was that writers will soon be adding car chases and explosions to their little personal narrative fictions in order to hold the readers' attention.

As someone steeped (like a bag of tea) in the highest traditons of objective journalism, I find it impossible to watch an entire half hour of CNN.

 
At 4:29 PM, Blogger L7 said...

That "quite rightly" is, I think, crap, because I think most people have some pretty good (true) stories in them.

About the fiction-being-presented-as-nonfiction thing, well, I agree. No one likes being lied to. (Or being lied about.) Is it possible that so many people, writers included, lie so much to themselves that they maybe can't always distinguish what is true? (I don't know why, but I hate to think it is only marketing.)


Maybe I am missing the point?

 
At 10:01 PM, Blogger Kia said...

Well, there's a beast of a question, L7.

But luckily for you, you just finished reading Martin Chuzzlewit and the answer to your question is there, in the incomparable Mrs. Gamp. Also, from this question I infer that you have not read nearly enough academic scholarly prose, where Pecksniffery rules as SOP.

Chuckling, If I understand Shafer correctly they'll be borrowing their kid brothers' car chases and explosions. I thought a half hour of CNN might be a bit of a stretch.

 
At 5:05 PM, Blogger John said...

Hi, G.G. You sure got a lotta gall and gumption, and a measure of irascibility, and some orneriness and honor (thanks to your great entertainer who taught you "life is wherever you find it," and wherever you don't it isn't, so who gives a fuck if it's fact or fiction), and a lovely-splendid way of dressing down a person. Damn lovely. Damn splendid. --Your old friend, John

 
At 10:11 PM, Blogger Kia said...

John,

It's about time you showed up. Come back here often.

 
At 10:12 PM, Blogger Kia said...

John,

It's about time you showed up. Come back here often.

 
At 12:46 PM, Blogger Shots said...

Thanks for a very interesting and thoughtful post on an issue that needs debating. I think sales issues and the growth of what this reviewer calls misery lit are central to what's going on.

I pitched a book about a girl growing up on a sink estate to publishers. It was a walk in the park compared to something like Dave Pelzer but, as a novel, many rejected it as too dark. Some, you could tell, were desperate for it be a memoir and disappointed when it wasn't.

Then again, I quite enjoy the work of Jenny Diski, who writes some very interesting travel memoirs. One of the things that makes these so colourful is the way she hints she perhaps hasn't been anywhere near the places she is writing about. Playful? Or dishonest? I can't decide. And yet I think there's enough truth in the themes she's really interested in (life and people, not places) so that it doesn't matter if she's made up the setting.

Maybe it depends what you're lying about as to whether it's harmful or not. It's one thing to pretend you've been to Antartica, another altogether to say you were abused by your uncle and beated to near death by your mum.

 
At 6:05 PM, Blogger buckner said...

This post reminds me of an incident in one of Marvin Mudrick's classes. Mudrick sometimes talked about his dislike of social functions such as cocktail and dinner parties. He thought the conversation was forced, and he was uncomfortable with the way people stood around holding drinks. Since he didn't drink alcohol he had trouble figuring out what to do with his hands.

One day he came into class complaining about a dinner party he'd been forced to go to over the weekend at the house of a collegue in the English Department. He was indignant that the professor's wife had served meatloaf at the party. "I could have had this at home!" he said, and then he went on: "To top it off, after she put the meatloaf on the table she turned and offered me a knife and asked if I'd like to carve!" The students broke out laughing.

Later some students were talking about the class. One of the students was upset about the story Mudrick told. She'd visited him earlier in the day and he had told her about the meatloaf, but he said nothing about being asked to carve. She was sure he lied in class to embellish the story.

I suppose no harm was done. It made a much better story.

 
At 1:15 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's truthiness, borrowed from political marketing.

 
At 11:12 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Victor Cruz Kids Jersey axiotakix
Broncos Peyton Manning Jersey axiotakix
Patrick Willis Kids Jersey axiotakix
http://www.authenticniketexansjerseys.com

 
At 9:12 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

mainlink: hover color: #1F98C7;text-decoration: underline; author img float: left;margin: 0px 7px 0px 0px;a:hover text-decoration: underline;span Apart from the aforementioned[url=http://www.AldonSmithJersey.net]Aldon Smith Jersey[/url]
viewers of The Book of Eli may be surprised at the amount of religiosity[url=http://www.brandonmarshalljersey.com]www.brandonmarshalljersey.com[/url]
Christianity namely[url=http://www.WesWelkerJersey.net]Wes Welker Womens Jersey[/url]
that plays a central theme throughout the moviemetadata spanDrink a lot of water" February The IBM Preliminary Manual of Information uses decimal arithmetic for powers of ten[url=http://www.cheapjerseyslimited.com]www.cheapjerseyslimited.com[/url]
without prefixesAs you move to lower-numbered wood golf clubs down to the driver[url=http://www.officialbearsjerseysstore.com]www.officialbearsjerseysstore.com[/url]
the ball will normally travel farther
twitreply > span background-position: 0px 3px; div Power: Most smaller corner rounding machines that are available on the market are manual and require you to pull a handle to round the corners of your documents Just as the game has become completely commercialized[url=http://www.AndrewLuckJerseynike.com]www.AndrewLuckJerseynike.com[/url]
the standards have similarly gone up and soccer drilling is therefore not as simplified as it used to be The portion between the wrap and cap at the very bottom of the cue is called the butt sleeve Challenge gives you a certain amount of time and money as with career you don�have these limitations

 
At 3:49 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

With your player whom has many abilities this game can be played for long periods of time without getting boreddittoTweet span Hold business users accountable for the quality of the application along with the QC personnel Green takes a huge step forward this season and propels himself into the discussion of who is the next big time wide receiver the NFL will see
timestamp a Knowing your projects[url=http://www.nikepatriotsjersey.com/nike-stevan-ridley-womens-jersey]Stevan Ridley Jersey[/url]
your priorities[url=http://www.nikemiamidolphinsshop.com]Reggie Bush Jersey[/url]
the equipment available to you and the correct binding style for your needs are all vital factors when coming to a conclusiontimestamp atimestamp a" - Richard Schickel[url=http://www.authenticnikefalconsjerseys.com/michael+turner+falcons+jersey+nike-c-9_14.html]Michael Turner Jersey[/url]
Time (9/23/74) On DVD: The Longest Yard Lockdown Edition (Paramount[url=http://www.authenticnikeBengalsshop.com]Andy Dalton Jersey[/url]
2005) Ten More Prison Movie GemsI Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang (1932) Reform School Girls (1986) Brubaker (1980) The Big House (1930) 20[url=http://www.nikeindianapoliscoltsshop.com]Andrew Luck Jersey[/url]
000 Years in Sing Sing (1932) Devil's Island (1939) Bad Boys (1983) The Hurricane (1999) Kiss of the Spider Woman (1985) Stir Crazy (1980) One sheet movie poster: Paul Muni in I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang (1932)Images CreditAll images courtesy Heritage Auction Galleries[url=http://www.nikedolphinsshop.com]Reggie Bush Womens Jersey[/url]
Dallas[url=http://www.nikeBearsauthenticjerseys.com]Alshon Jeffery Jersey[/url]
TexasThe top 20 games on the IphoneAll these games are compatible with 1st[url=http://www.nikepatriotsjersey.com]Wes Welker Elite Jersey[/url]
2nd and 3rd generation iPod touches and iphonesdittoTweet span

 
At 5:29 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

5xMyt cheap ghd
lZfq ugg store
bNwd michael kors purses
2pEdb GHD Hair Straightener
7lVxw burberry outlet online
8uWld bottes ugg pas cher
8nVan ghd nz
1lEqw louis vuitton handbags
9iUso michael kors purses
4yDok ghd straighteners
8jFfa cheap ugg boots
7hXod discount nfl jerseys
3sSmi michael kors handbags
2bIqq Lisseur GHD
1bMmw discount ugg boots

 
At 3:13 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

nOmw ghd hair straightener
qEcn cheap uggs
gIml michael kors sale
2fNtm GHD Hair Straightener
9qJry burberry on sale
3gXcp bottes ugg pas cher
1lGny ghd
5aAgx louis vuitton purses
9iMnf michael kors purses
6aDbr ghd sale
9aQnn ugg sale
4oVdq nike nfl jerseys
8mPzt michael kors outlet
6cVxq GHD Pas Cher
0oIhu ugg boots

 
At 12:55 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello. Facebook takes a [url=http://casino2013.webs.com/]craps online[/url] move on on 888 casino freight: Facebook is expanding its efforts to push aside further real-money gaming to millions of British users after announcing a wrestle with with the online gambling found search for 888 Holdings.And Bye.

 
At 7:35 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

[url=http://longchampsoldesk.exteen.com/]sacs longchamps[/url] Behavioral - Behavioral anger has a very physical component to it, where Hot Sale Women Mulberry Somerset Soft Leather Tote Bag Black,All In Good Quality And Fashion Style. the anger causes you to physically take action in some way shape or form. Sometimes, there is a desire to physically attack the subject causing the enraged feelings, usually a person. It is expressed through trouble-making, physical attack, and defiance..
[url=http://space.canoe.ca/longchampbagsd/blog/]longchamp soldes[/url] Create a tent out of the foil by bringing together the two short ends. Fold the ends over at least three times to seal tightly. Then Mulberry Handbags Store offer Mulberry bags, Online shop sale Mulberry Zip Around Travel Wallet Black for Women for sale fold over the two open sides in the same way to create a pouch. To make a shoe bag cut your chosen fabric to 50cm by 30 cm. Then fold the fabric with longer length (50cm) of fabric down 3 cm. Ensure the right side of the fabric is folded over the wrong and sew along the 3cm folded down section to secure.
[url=http://longchampsoldes.weebly.com/]longchamp soldes[/url] They can be worn day and evening, depending on the style, and permit a woman to use it hands-free. Some Crossbody bags even have convertible straps options, allowing them to transform in to shorter shoulder bags for additional versatility. These are perfect for those who have kids.. cheap uggs boots The moment wintertime heading, finest year or so to wear UGG Hunter wellies rather then the summer season. Through sizzling hot the summer season, continue to some adult females put on Classic Short ugg boots Best Seller Mulberry Women's Bayswater Leather Toter Brown Bag sale unique is worth the investment items. designed for manner, then again, this is really a false visual appeal that Ugg shoes or boots can be thinner. Any turth from Ugg.. Bottled water may be used as an ingredient in beverages, such as diluted juices or flavored bottled waters. However, beverages labeled as containing "sparkling water," "seltzer water," "soda water," "tonic water," or "club soda" are not included as bottled water under the FDA's regulations, because these beverages have historically been considered soft drinks. Consumers can buy purified water..

 
At 11:48 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

[url=http://buy-methylprednisolone.webspawner.com/]Solu-Medrol 8 mg
[/url] medrol bijsluiter
medrol backorder
medrol gyГіgyszer mire jГі

 
At 10:17 PM, Blogger oakleyses said...

oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, kate spade outlet, oakley sunglasses, burberry outlet, nike air max, louis vuitton outlet, replica watches, prada outlet, ray ban sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, cheap oakley sunglasses, gucci handbags, replica watches, michael kors outlet, christian louboutin outlet, burberry handbags, oakley sunglasses, christian louboutin shoes, christian louboutin uk, michael kors outlet online, ray ban sunglasses, nike free, chanel handbags, louis vuitton, ugg boots, longchamp outlet, uggs outlet, jordan shoes, uggs on sale, tory burch outlet, michael kors outlet online, nike air max, polo outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet online, tiffany jewelry, longchamp outlet, oakley sunglasses wholesale, tiffany and co, nike outlet, uggs outlet, ugg boots, prada handbags, louis vuitton outlet, christian louboutin, louis vuitton, michael kors outlet online

 
At 10:18 PM, Blogger oakleyses said...

north face, sac vanessa bruno, true religion jeans, michael kors, vans pas cher, nike blazer pas cher, nike roshe, kate spade, mulberry uk, air max, hollister pas cher, nike air force, oakley pas cher, true religion outlet, michael kors outlet, longchamp pas cher, nike air max uk, ray ban pas cher, abercrombie and fitch uk, nike roshe run uk, polo ralph lauren, nike tn, ralph lauren uk, nike free run, lululemon canada, guess pas cher, coach outlet, converse pas cher, hogan outlet, north face uk, hollister uk, true religion outlet, nike free uk, michael kors pas cher, timberland pas cher, coach purses, replica handbags, coach outlet store online, sac longchamp pas cher, louboutin pas cher, nike air max uk, sac hermes, burberry pas cher, michael kors, ray ban uk, new balance, polo lacoste, true religion outlet, jordan pas cher, nike air max

 
At 10:19 PM, Blogger oakleyses said...

giuseppe zanotti outlet, nike air max, north face outlet, timberland boots, valentino shoes, north face outlet, babyliss, iphone 6 cases, iphone 5s cases, mac cosmetics, reebok outlet, ferragamo shoes, celine handbags, abercrombie and fitch, louboutin, nike huaraches, lululemon, soccer shoes, hollister clothing, new balance shoes, iphone 6s cases, mcm handbags, jimmy choo outlet, iphone 6s plus cases, s6 case, hermes belt, longchamp uk, ipad cases, wedding dresses, mont blanc pens, hollister, nfl jerseys, bottega veneta, iphone 6 plus cases, ghd hair, herve leger, ralph lauren, chi flat iron, instyler, p90x workout, oakley, soccer jerseys, beats by dre, nike roshe run, vans outlet, iphone cases, nike trainers uk, baseball bats, insanity workout, asics running shoes

 
At 10:20 PM, Blogger oakleyses said...

canada goose uk, supra shoes, pandora jewelry, louis vuitton, canada goose, thomas sabo, toms shoes, barbour uk, barbour, hollister, pandora jewelry, wedding dresses, canada goose, moncler outlet, canada goose outlet, moncler, canada goose jackets, juicy couture outlet, coach outlet, marc jacobs, moncler outlet, links of london, louis vuitton, replica watches, louis vuitton, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, karen millen uk, ugg, montre pas cher, pandora uk, canada goose outlet, ugg pas cher, doke gabbana, ray ban, converse outlet, converse, lancel, swarovski crystal, moncler, vans, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, pandora charms, juicy couture outlet, ugg uk, louis vuitton, doudoune moncler, swarovski, hollister, gucci, canada goose outlet, nike air max, moncler

 
At 3:03 AM, Anonymous serrurier Marseille said...

C’est avec beaucoup de plaisir que j’ai lu votre article.Merci de l’avoir publié. serrurier Marseille,
Merci pour toutes ces infos, voici une bonne lecture. serrurier J’ai appris différentes choses en vous lisant, merci à vous. Bonne journée à tout le monde !
Je vous recommande mes sites web !;serrurier paris, ouverture de porte pas cher serrurier marseille nous sommes a votre disposition, plombier, electricien nous sommes a votre ecoute, serrurier vous avez un bon article, cafard j'aime lire votre blog, plombier paris rien a dire une bonne lecture, punaise de lit Merci pour votre site web , serrurier brest
serrurier lyon superbe site, serrurier grenoble je vais vous suivre,
serrurier marseille ,depannage serrure , cylindre je vous en pris continuez votre travail qui est vraiment très intéressante pour ma part je suisserrurier marseille, serrurier rennes , serrurier metz , serrurier cannes , serrurier liege ,serrurier saint etienne, vitrier a votre disposition fenetre paris pour une installation pas chère

 
At 5:56 AM, Blogger Esraa Abbas said...

http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/boards-cleaning-companies-6.html
http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/boards-cleaning-companies-5.html
http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/boards-cleaning-companies-4.html
http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/boards-cleaning-companies-3.html
http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/boards-cleaning-companies-2.html
http://www.prokr.net/2016/09/boards-cleaning-companies.html

 
At 6:14 PM, Blogger roba. gad2 said...

https://decor-ksa.com/
http://caravank.com/factory/
http://caravank.com/for-sale-in-riyadh/
http://caravank.com/withdrawn-for-sale/

 

Post a Comment

<< Home